Introduction
“Whatever’s Right” is a notable track by The Monkees, often considered an underrated gem within their extensive catalog. It appeared on their 1969 album Instant Replay, a period where the band was taking more creative control over their music. The song showcases a slightly more mature and introspective side of The Monkees, moving beyond their earlier bubblegum pop sound while retaining their knack for catchy melodies and harmonious vocals. “Whatever’s Right” offers a glimpse into the band’s evolving musical direction and remains a favorite among dedicated fans for its thoughtful lyrics and appealing arrangement.
About The Composition
- Title: Whatever’s Right
- Artist: The Monkees
- Composer: Michael Nesmith
- Premiere Date: 1969
- Album/Opus/Collection: Instant Replay
- Genre: Pop Rock
Background
By the time of the Instant Replay album, The Monkees were asserting more control over their songwriting and instrumental contributions. “Whatever’s Right” was written by Michael Nesmith, known for his more country-rock influenced style within the band. Its inclusion on the album reflects this shift towards a more diverse and artistically driven sound. The song stands out from their earlier, more commercially focused hits, offering a deeper lyrical and musical texture that resonated with a growing segment of their fanbase.
Musical Style
“Whatever’s Right” features a melodic pop-rock arrangement with a slightly melancholic undertone. The instrumentation often includes acoustic and electric guitars, a steady rhythm section, and the band’s signature harmonious vocals. The tempo is generally moderate, allowing the thoughtful lyrics and the nuanced melody to take center stage. Nesmith’s songwriting often brought a slightly different flavor to The Monkees’ sound, and “Whatever’s Right” exemplifies this with its blend of pop sensibility and a touch of introspective rock.
Lyrics/Libretto
The lyrics of “Whatever’s Right” explore themes of uncertainty, searching for meaning, and the acceptance of whatever path life may take. The narrator seems to be at a crossroads, contemplating different possibilities and ultimately resigning themselves to the idea that the best course of action is simply “whatever’s right.” Lines like “I’ve been thinking ’bout the future, what it holds for me and you” and “Maybe we should try to find a different point of view, but whatever’s right is alright with me” convey a sense of contemplation and a willingness to go with the flow. The lyrics are more mature and reflective than some of their earlier pop anthems.
Performance History
While “Whatever’s Right” wasn’t a major single release, it was a significant track on the Instant Replay album and likely featured in some of The Monkees’ performances during that era. It has remained a beloved song among dedicated fans and often appears on deeper cuts compilations or when discussing the band’s more artistically driven later work. Its inclusion in reunion tours or special performances would likely be met with enthusiasm by longtime followers.
Cultural Impact
“Whatever’s Right” contributes to the narrative of The Monkees’ evolution as a band who, despite their manufactured beginnings, developed genuine musical talent and a desire for creative expression. Its presence on Instant Replay showcases their willingness to move beyond their initial image and explore more mature themes and musical styles. The song resonates with fans who appreciate this later period of their career and recognize the depth of their musical abilities.
Legacy
The legacy of “Whatever’s Right” lies in its representation of The Monkees’ artistic growth and Michael Nesmith’s songwriting contributions to the band. It’s a reminder that beyond their pop hits, they created more nuanced and introspective music that continues to be appreciated by their dedicated fanbase. The song’s thoughtful lyrics and appealing melody have allowed it to endure as an underrated gem within The Monkees’ rich and varied catalog.
Conclusion
“Whatever’s Right” is a compelling example of The Monkees’ later work, showcasing a more mature and introspective side of the band. Michael Nesmith’s songwriting and the band’s harmonious delivery create a thoughtful and melodically pleasing track that explores themes of uncertainty and acceptance. While perhaps not as widely known as their chart-topping hits, “Whatever’s Right” remains a cherished song among fans who appreciate the depth and evolution of The Monkees’ music.