Beyond the Festivities: Finding Compassion in Toby Keith’s Rendition of “Pretty Paper”

 

About The Song

Toby Keith, while often known for his upbeat anthems and commanding stage presence, also possesses a deep appreciation for the power of a well-crafted story, particularly when it comes to songs that explore the more somber and reflective aspects of the human experience. His diverse catalog reveals a willingness to tackle themes of loneliness, loss, and the struggles of everyday people, often overlooked amidst the hustle and bustle of modern life. This ability to connect with the more vulnerable side of the human condition resonates with an older, educated audience that appreciates his depth and his grounding in the storytelling traditions of country music.

Originally written and recorded by Willie Nelson in 1963, and covered by Toby Keith as a part of his album “Christmas to Christmas” in 1995, “Pretty Paper” stands as a poignant example of a Christmas song that looks beyond the tinsel and lights to focus on the less fortunate during the holiday season. The song tells the story of a street vendor selling pencils and wrapping paper, a real-life individual Nelson encountered in Fort Worth, Texas. The vendor’s physical limitations and his perseverance in the face of adversity serve as a stark reminder that not everyone experiences the holidays with joy and abundance.

Musically, Keith’s version of “Pretty Paper” likely retains the song’s inherent melancholy while incorporating elements of his own signature style. The arrangement probably features a blend of traditional instruments, such as acoustic guitar, fiddle, and steel guitar, creating a sound that is both familiar and distinctly country. Keith’s voice, typically known for its strength, likely adopts a more subdued and empathetic tone, conveying the compassion and sadness inherent in the song’s narrative.

The lyrics of “Pretty Paper” paint a vivid picture of the street vendor, highlighting his struggles and the indifference he often faces from passersby. Keith’s rendition likely stays true to Nelson’s original lyrics, allowing the powerful story to speak for itself. The focus remains on the vendor’s plight, his resilience, and the simple act of kindness that can make a difference during the holiday season.

For an older, educated audience, Toby Keith’sPretty Paper” offers a moving and thought-provoking take on the Christmas season. It’s a song that resonates with those who understand that the holidays can be a difficult time for many, and that compassion and empathy are essential ingredients of the true Christmas spirit. The song’s message is a reminder to look beyond the surface of holiday cheer and to remember those who may be struggling. “Pretty Paper” showcases Toby Keith’s ability to embrace a classic song and deliver a performance that is both respectful of the original and infused with his own unique artistry, making it a powerful and poignant addition to the vast catalog of Christmas music.

Video